Grillo, Aguilar, Leah, Santi & Turco (2018) – Prosody of classic garden path sentences: The horse raced faster when embedded

Prosody of classic garden path sentences: The horse raced faster when embedded
Nino Grillo, Miriam Aguilar, Roberts Leah, Andrea Santi, Giuseppina Turco
direct link:
January 2018
Prosody, it is assumed, does not always disambiguate syntax. We investigate one classic case at point from the psycholinguistics literature: garden path sentences involving the main-verb vs. reduced relative clause contrast (the horse raced past the barn (and) fell). Despite their centrality in shaping theories of sentence processing, no experimental work to date has investigated the prosody of these sentences. We show that, contrary to previous assumptions (Fodor 2002, Wagner and Watson 2010), this contrast is prosodically disambiguated, but that this disambiguation can only be observed when the relevant clauses are embedded within a matrix clause which provides a baseline pace. Prosodic disambiguation obtains through pace modulation, with faster pace associated with the embedded/reduced relative reading and regular pace (no change) with main verb analysis. The essential contribution of the matrix sentence is to provide a baseline pace without which it is impossible to establish whether a change took place. Importantly, duration is solely determined by prosody and independent from complexity: faster pace is associated with the more complex structure.

Format: [ pdf ]
Reference: lingbuzz/003868
(please use that when you cite this article)
Published in: Speech Prosody 2018
keywords: syntax-prosody interface, complexity, garden path, pace, embedding vs. sisterhood, syntax, phonology